Protesters flooded the streets of New York City after a judge ruled that Mahmoud Khalil, a Columbia University activist, could be deported. The Trump administration says Khalil’s pro-Palestinian protests created a hostile environment for Jewish students and hurt American foreign policy. Supporters claim the decision attacks free speech, but many conservatives argue it’s a necessary step to protect Jewish safety and national interests.
Khalil helped lead protests against Israel’s actions in Gaza, including campus encampments that critics called antisemitic. Federal agents arrested him in March, and a Louisiana immigration judge later agreed with Secretary of State Marco Rubio’s claim that Khalil’s activism undermines U.S. foreign policy. The judge gave his lawyers until April 23 to appeal, but conservatives say the ruling shows strength against chaos on college campuses.
The Trump administration has cracked down on universities accused of tolerating antisemitism, cutting funding and targeting activists. This aligns with Project Esther, a plan by conservative groups to use immigration laws against pro-Palestinian voices. Supporters say stopping hate speech protects Jewish students, while detractors call it censorship.
Protesters in Times Square and Union Square rallied in the rain, claiming Khalil’s case sets a dangerous precedent. But critics argue the demonstrations ignore how antisemitism has spiked since the Gaza war began. They point to harassment of Jewish students and vandalism as proof that stronger measures are needed.
Khalil’s wife, an American citizen, is pregnant and says the separation is unjust. However, the administration insists noncitizens who violate visa terms or promote hatred lose the right to stay. Over 300 student visas have been revoked under similar policies, with officials stressing that foreign students must follow U.S. laws.
The judge’s decision highlights a growing divide. Liberals see it as an attack on free speech, while conservatives applaud it as a stand against radical activism. The Heritage Foundation’s Project Esther, which inspired parts of the crackdown, aims to stop protests it claims are tied to Hamas.
Columbia University lost $400 million in federal funding for failing to protect Jewish students, signaling broader consequences for schools. The administration warns more funding cuts and deportations will follow if universities don’t control campus unrest.
As Khalil’s legal battle continues, the debate over free speech versus national security intensifies. Conservatives argue the U.S. must prioritize safety and alliances like Israel over disruptive protests, while the left vows to keep fighting. The outcome could shape how America handles dissent and foreign policy for years.
