The recent clash between Douglas Murray and Dave Smith on Joe Rogan’s podcast exploded into a battle for the soul of the political Right. Murray, a staunch defender of Western values and Israel, faced off against Smith, a libertarian comic who dismisses Zionism as racism. Their fiery debate exposed deep cracks in conservative thought—patriots vs. populists, experts vs. entertainers.
Murray blasted Rogan for giving airtime to unqualified voices pushing conspiracy theories about Gaza and Ukraine. He warned that letting comedians play geopolitical analysts risks spreading dangerous lies. Smith shot back, claiming free speech means anyone can opine—even without degrees or facts. Rogan mostly stayed quiet, letting the two duke it out.
Things got personal when Smith accused Israel of committing “genocide” against Palestinians. Murray, who’s tracked Middle Eastern conflicts for decades, fact-checked him hard. He reminded Smith that Hamas terrorists burned babies alive on October 7th. Supporting Israel’s right to defend itself isn’t elitism—it’s basic moral clarity.
Rogan later turned on Murray, mocking his English degree and dismissing expertise altogether. “You’re not Shakespeare!” he barked. This shocked many conservatives who see Rogan as an ally. Letting smears against Israel slide while attacking serious thinkers like Murray? Not a good look.
The real gut punch? Smith is Jewish. Using his heritage to legitimize anti-Israel lies felt like betrayal. True conservatives know: Standing with the Jewish state isn’t optional. It’s about fighting evil that wants us all dead. Smith’s words don’t just hurt Israel—they embolden terrorists aiming for America next.
Murray stood firm, calling out the “fake experts” Rogan platforms—grifters rewriting history to blame the West for everything. Experience matters. You wouldn’t take medical advice from a clown. Why trust comedians on wars shaping our future?
This feud isn’t just about two guys arguing. It’s about whether the Right values truth or tweets. Murray fights for facts, faith, and freedom. Smith’s “anti-war” act downplays enemies who slaughter innocents. Patriots can’t afford these divides. Either we unite against true threats, or we lose everything.
The takeaway? Conservatives must choose: Will we defend civilization or let loudmouths burn it down? Rogan’s middle-ground act isn’t working. Murray’s courage shows the path—hold the line, speak truth, and never apologize for protecting what’s right.
