The question of Jesus’s identity and role remains a fundamental point of divergence between Islam and Christianity. While both faiths revere Jesus as a pivotal figure, their theological interpretations clash on core doctrines, sparking ongoing debate. Here’s a breakdown of key disagreements:
—
###
:
– Jesus is regarded as a and (Abd Allah), not divine. The Quran explicitly rejects the concept of the Trinity, stating: “Do not say ‘Three’… God is but one God” (Quran 4:171).
– His miracles, such as healing the blind and raising the dead, are attributed to God’s permission, not inherent divinity.
:
– The New Testament repeatedly affirms Jesus’s divinity (e.g., John 1:1, 10:30), a cornerstone of Christian theology. Critics argue that Islam’s denial contradicts biblical accounts and early Church teachings.
– The Quran’s rejection of Jesus as the “Son of God” is seen as a misinterpretation of Christian doctrine, which emphasizes a unique relational—not biological—sonship.
—
###
:
– Muslims believe Jesus ; instead, God made it appear as though he was, then raised him to heaven. The Quran states: “They did not kill him, nor did they crucify him” (4:157).
– Jesus’s eventual return to Earth is prophesied to restore justice before Judgment Day.
:
– Historical and biblical accounts universally affirm Jesus’s crucifixion and resurrection. Scholars note that the Quran’s denial (circa 7th century) conflicts with 1st-century sources like the Gospels and Roman records.
– Critics argue that dismissing the crucifixion undermines the theological foundation of salvation in Christianity.
—
###
:
– The Quran claims to “confirm” earlier scriptures (e.g., the Injeel, or Gospel) but asserts they were corrupted over time. Muslims follow Jesus’s teachings as presented in the Quran, such as monotheism and moral uprightness.
– Miracles like Jesus speaking as an infant or creating clay birds are derived from apocryphal texts, not the canonical Gospels.
:
– The Quran’s reliance on non-canonical sources (e.g., the Infancy Gospel of Thomas) is cited as evidence of historical inaccuracies.
– While the Quran instructs Muslims to respect the Bible (e.g., Sura 3:3), it rejects key Christian doctrines, creating a theological paradox.
—
###
:
– Jesus is a (Al-Masih) who will return to defeat the Antichrist (Dajjal), establish peace, and affirm Islam. His role is secondary to Muhammad, the “seal of the prophets”.
:
– Christianity views Jesus’s Second Coming as the culmination of divine authority, not a reaffirmation of Islamic teachings. The absence of crucifixion/resurrection in Islamic eschatology is seen as stripping Jesus of his redemptive purpose.
—
###
The divide centers on (Quran vs. Bible) and (prophet vs. divine Savior). While Islam honors Jesus as a revered messenger, it rejects core Christian tenets—his divinity, crucifixion, and role in salvation—as deviations from “pure” monotheism. Critics argue these denials overlook historical evidence and the theological coherence of Christianity. Dialogue remains challenging, as each faith’s claims are rooted in mutually exclusive revelations.
